For a couple years during middle school I was—somewhat unhealthily—obsessed with astrology (so if your Mercury is in retrograde I can totally sympathize), and one of the reasons why I put so much stock in it was because it described human relationships so well. And not in the “If your sign is ____, take my word for it that you are compatible with a ____ or a ____” kind of way. Once you read books on the subject, they start explaining why two particular types of people are likely to get along well (or not) when in close proximity. One of the relationships they covered was Scorpio-on-Scorpio. While Scorpios are the royal pains of the zodiac and are bad enough on their own, two Scorpios living together is a bad mix.
You’ll just have to trust me that in this claim, astrology is spot on. It’s exemplified particularly well in my father and I, who are both Scorpios. In fact, the doctors said I would be born on my father’s birthday (although I wasn’t), which is an ugly sort of reminder of how similar we are.
That said, I don’t have the patience to beat myself up in this post, but once I get on to ranting about my father, just know that after an hour passes I'll calm down, read it through, and realize that I’m just talking about myself anyway.
The anger on which this post is fueled is rooted in something I said over dinner tonight, while my family and I were having some political discussion or another. (As a side note, never EVER get into political arguments with me face to face. At a certain point if we can’t come round to a compromise, I have to fight not to say something cutting and personal about you. I feel no healthier emerging from debates than I do from three-mile runs, although both may be healthy things.) Anyway, my dad seemingly had an honest misunderstanding about the issue, and stubbornly kept holding to his argument; meanwhile my mother, sister, and I all tried to reason with him, but he kept going as if he was completely deaf. So I, as is my bad habit, made a personal remark: “Maybe you’re right and everyone else is wrong, as usual.” My mom gave me the “you’re-not-being-constructive” look, so I stood up, took a deep breath, and left her to lose the argument on her own.
Of course, I could be certain that this was not the end. By saying something negative about my dad to his face, I had sealed my fate and he would surely approach me later in the evening, declaring that my statement about him was entirely wrong and that I should stop always thinking of him as a bad person.
My father did not fail me. As soon as I dared to step outside my bedroom, he called out “Wanda!” and the conversation progressed as follows:
ME: Yes?
FATHER: What were you saying tonight about me being always wrong and everyone else always right?
ME: Yes, I said that. It was a personal comment and I shouldn’t have said it in the middle of an argument. I’m sorry I said it.
FATHER: Well, that’s not the end of it. Are you supposed to be able to make a statement about me as a person, at the dinner table, and then say that you’re sorry you said it, and I’m just supposed to take that?
ME: Well…this time, yes. If you can.
FATHER: Why did you have to say that about me?
ME: Well…I was a little…miffed.
FATHER: Why?
ME: I was just commenting on a pattern of yours that tends to annoy me, where you’ll hold your position in an argument in spite of all odds, and you make it impossible for anyone to reason with you.
FATHER: I do not.
ME: Well, see, there you go. It’s so hard to explain anything to you because you refuse to listen.
FATHER: No one was trying to explain anything tonight.
ME: Yes they were, because it seemed like you were under a misunderstanding, so we were all trying to explain it.
FATHER: Nothing was being explained because there was nothing to explain. And it’s not “we all.” There were people taking my side.
ME: …no.
FATHER: Yes there were.
(etc etc etc, for a while)
FATHER: Hey! Let’s say that this statement you made about me, your feelings about me, have no grounds—they’re completely ungrounded—so what does that say about you as a person?
ME: I don’t think that applies, to any situation, to anyone. I think someone’s feelings about somebody else always have some grounds.
FATHER: Well, I’m saying it does apply! What if I’m right? What does that say about you?
ME: That I’m…wrong?
FATHER: No, what does it say about you as a person?
ME: …I don’t know, dad.
FATHER: See, who’s stubborn now? I think you do know, and you don’t want to admit it because you don’t want to confront that part of yourself! You’re scared, because that would be unflattering to you, but you should take some time—I don’t mean necessarily now—to think about that, what that says about you as a person.
ME: So what you’re saying is—I should take a little time to assume that everything I think about you is wrong, and to reevaluate myself in the worst way based on that fact?
FATHER: I didn’t say think about yourself that way. You should be thinking about why you said what you said, because you’ve obviously got this huge store of dislike for me piled up that you can’t control, so it comes out in times like tonight! Why do you always have to think of me as the bad person? Why do you have to do that, knowing what it does to not only you, but to me, and to our relationship!
ME: Oh, get over yourself. Just because I said something about you doesn’t mean I’m always thinking of you as the enemy and the bad person.
FATHER: I didn’t say you’re always thinking of me as the enemy, or the bad person.
ME: Yes you did.
FATHER: No, I didn't.
ME: ...Nevertheless, if this says something about me as a person, I don't know what it is.
FATHER: I'll tell you what it is: it’s you. So you should think about that. But for now—
(gestures to the internet cable connected to my computer; I disconnect it before he can order me off the Internet) —yeah.
ME: (packing up, going back inside my room) Okay, okay. I'll go to bed now, and as soon as I think badly enough of myself I'll get to use the Internet again.
FATHER: What did you say?
ME: Because that’s how it works. (Coming back outside) I mean—
FATHER: Just—stop. Stop. Do you really want to argue more?
ME: Whenever—
FATHER: Do you or don’t you? Haven’t you done enough arguing for one night?
ME: Yes, but all I’m saying is—
FATHER: Just answer me. Because I don’t want to argue about this anymore.
ME: Why was that not a good enough excuse when I made it, but—
FATHER: Hey, you were the one who started this. So I’m asking you, do you want to keep fighting or do you want to stop?
ME: Well—yes, I do want to fight about one more thing—
FATHER: If you say one thing, then you’re back in.
ME: I just want to say that if there is any pent-up—not dislike, but anger—then it’s because of situations like this, where you get to come in and say your bit to me, and as soon as I try to say anything, you immediately tell me to stop—
FATHER: Hey, you said plenty!—
ME: You know what? Stop. Let’s stop.
(bedroom door slams)
If I could bear to go back and reread that argument, I’d put an asterisk next to each thing that I wish I hadn’t said, or had phrased differently—but that would take far too long. I’m worse at arguing than my dad than with anyone else, because I fluctuate between two mindsets:
- Just let this pass. Stay silent as he rants, and don’t say anything even remotely passionate, because you’ll end up saying things you’ll regret. As long as you keep clam, he’ll keep making a fool of himself, and will hopefully feel like an idiot later.
- Good God, defend yourself. He’s just proven himself to be so insane that keeping quiet won’t be any more effective than anything else will, and you don’t want to bottle up more anger.
Mindset 1, while it practically guarantees that I won’t say anything of value, is an excellent plan when dealing with my dad. As long as he’s the only one talking, he’ll actually remember what was said, which means that I get off Scot-free and he hopefully reviews his monologues and realizes that he needs help. Hypothetically speaking, of course—because I revert to Mindset 2 eventually every time. Mindset 2 is just plain stupid. I bottle up anger anyway, and saying angry things during an argument tends to make me more angry instead of releasing anything.
The point that I originally intended to make in this post was that my dad is impossible. If any negative accusation is directed at him, he responds in the way I just illustrated—to reprimand the accuser as much as possible for even suggesting that he could be less than perfect. Any statement against his character is not only unfair, it is absolutely ridiculous, and for this the unfortunate complainant should meditate and then repent for their sin.
The most significant time this has happened recently is when my mom told him that he tends to bully people during arguments. She said that she wasn’t alone in thinking so. My father responded by calling a family conference, in which he stated the accusation that he was a bully, and asked for our justifications for it. Being met with a hesitant (but constant) stream of grievances from all three of us, he nevertheless battled his way towards the conclusion that he was not a bully and that we were all absurd.
I agree with at least one thing that my father said tonight—random outbursts of anger are no good for a relationship. But this system that he seems to want, where if you can’t say something nice about him don’t say anything at all, seems no healthier.
Dad, you’re almost right. I do have a huge pent-up store of anger. But you wouldn’t have it any other way. If I wanted to handle my problems with you in a rational way, I’d have to come clean with you about them, in which case my complaints would inevitably be interrupted, twisted, and shot down. The argument would end with my walking away and thinking, as always, “How did he persuade me that I was wrong?”
I’m sorry this was such a long post, guys. But this way, if I ever mention in passing that my dad and I argued, you can imagine it went something like what you’ve read, so I won’t have to explain why I’m feeling shitty about him and even shittier about myself. And this way, you all know that astrology was right and two temperaments such as my dad’s and mine shouldn’t be brought together.
If any of you are acquainted with a Pisces, let me know.